Jiglu: Farmtalking: Discussion: Re: FMD future

Originally from: Farmtalking

I too would have liked them to have used what was available in 2001 but they didn't.

In, heaven forbid, the event of another outbreak – thank goodness – there are provisions for emergency vaccination and I hope they would use them.

However, we know it will only be ring vaccination if they do.

We have to try and improve what's available and the fact that scientists are willing to work together and hopefully, their Government's fund them, is nothing but good news.

If, when Fleming discovered penicillin, others had said 'We have an antibiotic mow so what's the point in spending more money on research to find better ones, I for one would not be alive today and neither would millions of others!

In fact, research into alternative antibiotics continues today and we should be delighted that it does.

Isn't what is proposed by Kitching et al, exactly what we want?
I can think of nothing better than the real possibility that we could eradicate the disease in this way and that is certainly what I want!

Author wrote:
We did not say we doubted their credibility Jane, we simply asked why? We
here in the UK cannot even use what is available now.
It does seem rather silly to my limited brain capacity
Coleen
----- Original Message -----
From: <...>
To: <...>
Sent: Tuesday, September 30, 2003 9:44 AM
Subject: Re: [farmtalking] FMD future – Some good news!
Hi Lina –
I got the information sent to me by – http://www.alphagalileo.org/index.cfm
one of the world's leading resources for scientific research news and a
highly respected source.
I'm so sorry that you seem to dismiss this information, thinking the
proposed international research is needless.
During and since FMD in 2001, I and many others have constantly tried to
share information that we thought was not only relevent to our appalling
situation but might help to alleviate it both for ourselves and world-wide.
The veterinary scientists involved in this proposed programm are world
experts in their field and our own Dr. Paul Kitching has personally been
extremely helpful to us both in the general information he has been willing
to share and to individual farmers affected by FMD.
The fact that he and Drs. McKenna, Jeggo and Paton are wanting to work
together and share research to provide us with an even better vaccine that
as Dr. Paton says, will not only protect livestock from becoming sick but
from becoming infected.
They aim to deliver what will be far more effective FMD vaccines and
sophisticated diagnostic tests than those available now which will ensure a
longer duration of immunity and that vaccinated animals are not confused
with infected animals.
I think they have every chance of succeeding at remarkably low cost and
vaccination will become not only an acceptable option but couldl IMO become
the 'norm' for control of an outbreak in traditionally disease-free areas
and we really could look forward to the eradication of the disease.
Best wishes, Jane
Author wrote:
Hi Jane,
I don't know where you got this article from, but this
is a bit like re inventing another wheel. They already
have more effective FMD vaccine for all seven strains
of FMD. And they have the diagnostic tests as well.
So why would they need 60 million dollars to invent
something that is already there?
Lina
--- ... wrote:
29 September 2003
FMD future: vaccines or funeral pyres?
Millions of animals could be needlessly slaughtered
and billions of dollars lost from economies, unless
the world backs an international science team to
develop new tools to fight foot-and-mouth disease
(FMD).
A group of world-leading researchers aims to develop
a more effective FMD vaccine and better diagnostic
tests that would enable livestock disease control
agencies to isolate and eventually eliminate the
disease. The team of scientists from the United
Kingdom, Canada, United States, and Australia, are
leading a call for international support for a bold
five-year research project.
"Foot-and-mouth disease is a global problem and it
requires a global solution," says project leader, Dr
Martyn Jeggo, Director of CSIRO Livestock
Industries' Australian Animal Health Laboratory
(AAHL). "Most countries probably can't afford the
burden of funding the necessary research, but the
world cannot afford to sit back and do nothing.
That's why we shall call on international donors for
support.
"We have the scientific capabilities and commitment
to successfully deliver this project. What is needed
is a commitment by the international community to
fund the work, which we estimate will cost US$60
million. This is a paltry sum compared to the
approximate US$12 billion cost of the 2001 FMD
outbreak in the UK.
With members drawn from AAHL, the UK's Institute for
Animal Health at Pirbright, the United States' Plum
Island Animal Disease Center, and Canada's National
Centre for Foreign Animal Disease, the team features
some of the world's leading experts in the
development of FMD vaccines and diagnostic tests.
Dr David Paton from the Institute for Animal Health
says currently available FMD vaccines can protect
animals from becoming sick but not from becoming
infected with the virus. In addition they require
several days to confer protection.
"In five years we aim to deliver more effective FMD
vaccines and sophisticated diagnostic tests which
will ensure a longer duration of immunity and that
vaccinated animals are not confused with infected
animals," Dr Paton says. "Vaccination would then
become a more acceptable option for control of an
outbreak in traditionally disease-free areas, like
Europe. "This would mean that, instead of having to
slaughter millions of animals simply because they
are suspected of being infected, a vaccination
program could be an alternative method of
controlling the spread of the disease.
Dr Paul Kitching of Canada's National Centre for
Foreign Animal Disease says it is "almost
inevitable" that there will be future outbreaks of
FMD in industrialised countries such as the UK,
Canada, US, Australia or New Zealand. "For a
relatively small investment, the international
community could dramatically improve its capacity to
deal with the scourge of FMD," he says.
Dr Paton continues, "Ultimately our aim has got to
be better control of FMD in those parts of the world
where the disease remains endemic. The Global
Rinderpest Eradication Programme is a success story
that could be copied in the case of FMD. Total
rinderpest eradication is now in sight. Whilst there
are a number of factors that have been critical to
this success, the availability of diagnostics and a
vaccine able to confer life-long immunity, has been
of crucial importance," he says.
Dr Tom McKenna of the Plum Island Animal Disease
Centre in the US says field-testing of candidate
vaccines developed by the research team could then
take place in collaboration with countries presently
infected with FMD. This would occur in consultation
with National Agricultural Research Systems (NARS),
including Onderstepoort Veterinary Institute, South
Africa, PanAftosa, South America, and Pakchong
Laboratory, Thailand.
--
If you want to share pictures, use the calendar, or
start a vote
visit http://www.smartgroups.com/groups/farmtalking
To leave the group, email:
...
Do you Yahoo!?
The New Yahoo! Shopping – with improved product search
http://shopping.yahoo.com
--
If you want to share pictures, use the calendar, or start a vote
visit http://www.smartgroups.com/groups/farmtalking
To leave the group, email: ...